Manchester United triumphed over Everton but the meeting at Goodison Park featured off-the-pitch and on-the-pitch controversy.
Dermot Gallagher, a former Premier League referee, has offered his assessment on why Ashley Young, an Everton defender, was not sent off following VAR’s review of a contentious diving call on Sunday afternoon.
The Toffees player seemed to dangle a leg out in the penalty box shortly after halftime, with Red Devils forward Anthony Martial tripping over the leg. Referee John Brooks initially booked a puzzled Martial for simulation and indicated a free kick in Everton’s favour.
The decision was inevitably sent to Stockley Park, where Brooks was sent to the monitor and VAR chose to reverse the on-field ruling. Gallagher commented on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch: “When I initially saw it, I assumed it was a penalty. It is challenging to argue that there was no foul since he planted his leg and dangled it, failing to catch the ball. I simply don’t think there is much else you can do when you see that save impose a penalty.
“I think Martial is quite happy to go after the ball, but the leg is planted. If you dangle at leg like that, you run the risk.
![](https://sportoclock.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/1-78-300x197.gif)
Once the decision had been made, opening goalscorer Alejandro Garnacho appeared to lead protestations that if the incident was a foul, Young should be booked. The defender had already been shown a yellow card in the match and a second booking would have been a red.
Gallagher reasoned: “The referee obviously thought it was careless. It possibly is a second yellow card, but I would not say it is guaranteed and the one thing I would say is to go from a dive for one player to a red card to another is quite a spectrum to travel. I just wonder, has the referee made that much of an error?”
Leave a Reply