There has been a lot of discussion about the three-minute VAR tape for Scott McTominay’s goal that was disallowed against Fulham.
When Alejandro Garnacho squared a free kick to Christian Eriksen at the far post, it was first given credit for a goal, setting up McTominay’s attempt in the eighth minute earlier this month.
However, following a protracted VAR review, referee John Brooks eventually reversed the goal because it was determined that Harry Maguire was not in the goal zone.
Maguire interfered with play by making a “clear attempt” to reach Eriksen’s free-kick.
Referee Brooks was urged to go to the pitchside monitor by VAR Jarred Gillett because the call for offside was subjective, as you can see in the video below.
PGMOL chairman Howard Webb gave an explanation on Match Officials: Mic’d Up explaining why the pitch-side monitor was used to rule out Harry Maguire’s goal against Fulham as offside.
“A simple offside stance is not a crime in and of itself. Everything relies on your actions while occupying that role, according to Webb.
It is against the law to interfere with play if you play the ball or touch it as an attacker when offside. such’s true, and the referee doesn’t have to look at the screen in such situation.
But as an attacker in an offside position, you might potentially break the law without ever touching the ball. Everything relies on your actions in that role, which requires evaluation by the
This is how the VAR audio was received on social media.
“Nothing says clear and obvious more than three and a half minutes checking an offside,” remarked one fan, while another stated, “The amount of activity here is ridiculous.” A few seconds of decision-making have been replaced by three and a half minutes, even if this is the right choice (subjective).
A third person said, “Killing the game. Just stop there and let the goal if the referee calls a goal and they are only able to determine an infringement by looking at the offside line forensically. Nobody would voice a complaint.
“So their problem is Maguire tries to play the ball,” a fourth person stated. Therefore, if Maguire just halts his sprint and makes
Leave a Reply